Journal Club Evaluation Form Template
Gather expert feedback effortlessly with our evaluation form
Struggling to collect and organize feedback on scientific papers from your peers? Our Journal Club Evaluation Form template is designed to help you capture insightful evaluations that enhance your discussions and encourage constructive critique among participants. With this template, you can streamline the feedback process, improve your team's analytical skills, and ensure that discussions remain focused and thorough. It also supports collaboration and provides WCAG-aligned labels for accessibility. Start using this live template today for efficient evaluations!
When to use this form
Use this form after each journal club meeting to capture clear, structured feedback. It helps program directors, faculty, fellows, residents, pharmacists, and students assess article selection, presenter skills, and relevance to practice. For example, in a residency program, you can compare sessions over a semester and see which formats drive stronger discussion. In a hospital pharmacy CE event, you can record takeaways and set follow-up actions. If you also rate individual presenters, pair it with the Peer evaluation form. When small teams co-present, add the Group evaluation form to gauge teamwork. For mentoring presenters between sessions, the Mentor evaluation form gives you a consistent coaching framework.
Must Ask Journal Club Evaluation Questions
- How clearly did the presenter state the clinical or research question?
Clarity up front lets you judge relevance and keeps participants aligned. It also trains presenters to frame PICO or hypotheses before diving into results.
- How appropriate and rigorous was the study design and methodology?
Rating design, bias risks, and sample size improves critical appraisal skills. It also guides better article selection for future sessions.
- What are the key findings, and how applicable are they to your practice or curriculum?
This ties evidence to action so the session leads to change. It helps you document practical takeaways and set follow-ups.
- How effectively did the presenter facilitate discussion and critical appraisal?
Assessing pacing, engagement, and questioning improves learning quality. Pair this with the Mentor evaluation form to guide targeted coaching.
- What one change will you implement based on this session?
A single, concrete commitment drives accountability. It also makes impact measurable when you review sessions across the term.
More Forms
- 100% Free - No Catches
- Collect Responses Today
- Tailor to your Look & Feel